Every lock on this page was tested. Every charge listed is documented. Every verdict was reached after repeated, methodical testing by trained reviewers.
We take no pleasure in this. We take a little pleasure in this.
These locks were sold to real people, marketed as security products, and trusted to protect homes, bikes, storage units, and valuables. They failed. Repeatedly. Embarrassingly. In some cases, instantly.
The public deserves to know. This is that knowledge.
We take no pleasure in this. We take a little pleasure in this.
These locks were sold to real people, marketed as security products, and trusted to protect homes, bikes, storage units, and valuables. They failed. Repeatedly. Embarrassingly. In some cases, instantly.
The public deserves to know. This is that knowledge.
§01 MUGSHOT FILES — WORST OFFENDERS
SHAME
GUILTY
CASE #NP-2026-001 // MASTER LOCK No.3
Filed: 03/2026

NP-2026-001
MASTER LOCK No. 3
Master Lock Co. // 1-1/8" Wide Brass Padlock
Opened with shim in 4.2 seconds
Picked clean with basic rake, 18 seconds
Bumped on first attempt
Sold as "security" without irony
Pick Time18 sec
Shim Time4.2 sec
Bump KeyYES
Our Score1.2/10
☠ DO NOT BUY. DO NOT USE. REPLACE IMMEDIATELY. ☠
SHAME
AVOID
CASE #NP-2026-002 // BRINKS 170-80051
Filed: 03/2026

NP-2026-002
BRINKS 170-80051
Brinks Home Security // 40mm Laminated Steel
Shackle cut with $12 bolt cutters in 1 strike
Picked in 31 seconds by a first-week student
Packaging claims "Hardened Steel" — not confirmed
Found on 1,400+ storage units worldwide
Pick Time31 sec
Cut Time1 hit
Bump KeyYES
Our Score1.8/10
☠ CRIMINALLY INADEQUATE FOR STORAGE USE ☠
— ✦ —
§02 WANTED POSTERS — STILL AT LARGE
These locks remain available for purchase at major retailers. They have not been recalled. They continue to be sold as security products. They should not be.
SHAME
NoPryZone.com OFFICIAL NOTICE
WANTED
DEAD OR REPLACED

STANLEY S828-228
Last seen: Hardware stores nationwide.
Known associates: Cable locks, cheap hasps.
Crimes: Opened with improvised pick in 45 seconds. Shackle notch unsecured. Disc stack only 3 deep.
Considered inadequate and mildly embarrassing.
Known associates: Cable locks, cheap hasps.
Crimes: Opened with improvised pick in 45 seconds. Shackle notch unsecured. Disc stack only 3 deep.
Considered inadequate and mildly embarrassing.
REWARD FOR REPLACEMENT
YOUR SAFETY
YOUR SAFETY
Contact: NoPryZone.com
GUILTY
NoPryZone.com OFFICIAL NOTICE
WANTED
DEAD OR REPLACED

MASTER LOCK 140
Last seen: School lockers, gym bags, luggage.
Known associates: False sense of security.
Crimes: Combination cracked by feel in under 2 minutes. Shackle shimmed in 5 seconds. Used on 40M+ lockers.
An international menace to gym bags.
Known associates: False sense of security.
Crimes: Combination cracked by feel in under 2 minutes. Shackle shimmed in 5 seconds. Used on 40M+ lockers.
An international menace to gym bags.
REWARD FOR REPLACEMENT
PEACE OF MIND
PEACE OF MIND
Contact: NoPryZone.com
AVOID
NoPryZone.com OFFICIAL NOTICE
WANTED
DEAD OR REPLACED

MASTER LOCK 3KA
Last seen: Construction sites, job boxes.
Crimes: Convenience key cuts sold separately. Key profile widely available. 4-pin cylinder, no security pins.
If they sell the key separately, so can we say anything good about it? No.
Crimes: Convenience key cuts sold separately. Key profile widely available. 4-pin cylinder, no security pins.
If they sell the key separately, so can we say anything good about it? No.
REWARD FOR REPLACEMENT
ACTUAL SECURITY
ACTUAL SECURITY
Contact: NoPryZone.com
GUILTY
NoPryZone.com OFFICIAL NOTICE
WANTED
DEAD OR REPLACED

BRINKS 50mm BRASS
Last seen: Garden gates, sheds, gates.
Crimes: Springs corrode in 18 months. Picked in 22 seconds. Brass body sheared with basic tools. Sold as "weather resistant."
Weather resistant. Not much else resistant.
Crimes: Springs corrode in 18 months. Picked in 22 seconds. Brass body sheared with basic tools. Sold as "weather resistant."
Weather resistant. Not much else resistant.
REWARD FOR REPLACEMENT
DRY BELONGINGS
DRY BELONGINGS
Contact: NoPryZone.com
— ✦ —
§03 SUPPLEMENTARY CASE FILES
WORDLOCK PL-004 — "WORD COMBINATION" PADLOCK
The WordLock uses letters instead of numbers so you can set a "word" as your combination. The manufacturer says this is easier to remember.
There are 10,000 possible numeric combinations on a standard combo lock. There are approximately 4-letter English words — far fewer than 10,000. A targeted dictionary attack reduces the search space dramatically. Someone motivated and familiar with common words could work through likely combinations in minutes.
We set it to a common word. A tester who didn't know the word guessed it in 4 tries. The 4 tries took 90 seconds.
There are 10,000 possible numeric combinations on a standard combo lock. There are approximately 4-letter English words — far fewer than 10,000. A targeted dictionary attack reduces the search space dramatically. Someone motivated and familiar with common words could work through likely combinations in minutes.
We set it to a common word. A tester who didn't know the word guessed it in 4 tries. The 4 tries took 90 seconds.
☠ CLEVER IDEA. WORSE SECURITY.
DEFIANT SINGLE CYLINDER DEADBOLT — HOME DEPOT HOUSE BRAND
Sold at major hardware stores under the Defiant brand. ANSI Grade 3. Five pins, no security pins, no anti-pick features.
Standard residential installation. We picked it in 23 seconds on the first attempt. The strike plate it came with attached with 3/4" screws into hollow door trim — a single kick defeated the entire door assembly regardless of lock quality.
This is what most front doors in North America currently have installed.
Standard residential installation. We picked it in 23 seconds on the first attempt. The strike plate it came with attached with 3/4" screws into hollow door trim — a single kick defeated the entire door assembly regardless of lock quality.
This is what most front doors in North America currently have installed.
☠ EXTREMELY COMMON. EXTREMELY FIXABLE. READ OUR GUIDE.
§04 THE TABLE OF SHAME — ALL CASES SUMMARY
| LOCK | PICK TIME | SHIM/CUT | BUMP KEY | PRICE | VERDICT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Master Lock No. 3 | 18 sec | 4.2 sec | YES | $8.99 | ☠ AVOID |
| Brinks 170-80051 | 31 sec | 1 hit | YES | $12.49 | ☠ AVOID |
| Stanley S828-228 | 45 sec | Shimmed | YES | $9.99 | ✗ WEAK |
| Master Lock 140 | 2 min | 5 sec | N/A | $7.49 | ☠ AVOID |
| Master Lock 3KA | 1 min | Shimmed | YES | $11.99 | ✗ WEAK |
| Brinks 50mm Brass | 22 sec | Sheared | YES | $14.99 | ✗ WEAK |
| WordLock PL-004 | N/A | N/A | N/A | $11.99 | ✗ WEAK |
| Defiant Deadbolt | 23 sec | Frame fail | YES | $29.99 | ☠ AVOID |
SO WHAT DO YOU DO NOW?
You replace them. With something that works.
We have tested hundreds of locks. We know which ones deserve your trust.
>> Read: Best Deadbolts of 2026 — 18 Locks Ranked
>> Read: Best Padlocks That Won't Embarrass You
>> Read: How To Reinforce A Door Frame For Under $50
The locks on this page are still for sale. That is not our problem to solve. Buying them is.
We have tested hundreds of locks. We know which ones deserve your trust.
>> Read: Best Deadbolts of 2026 — 18 Locks Ranked
>> Read: Best Padlocks That Won't Embarrass You
>> Read: How To Reinforce A Door Frame For Under $50
The locks on this page are still for sale. That is not our problem to solve. Buying them is.